Homes, transport, Brexit and tuition fees key issues as politicians clash

By Alex Worrall and Matthew Barks

Political candidates hoping to represent Pudsey, Horsforth and Aireborough held a lively debate at Leeds Trinity University today.

Representatives from the Labour party, the Conservatives, the Liberal Democrats, the Yorkshire Party and the Green Party answered questions from the audience. An independent candidate also took part in the debate.

The former MP for the constituency was Conservative Stuart Andrew who was unable to attend and so a Conservative representative, Andrew Martin, filled his place.

First to speak was Yorkshire Party candidate Bob Buxton. Buxton serves on the Rawdon Parish Council and his agenda focuses on environmental and transport issues.

Buxton opposes all Greenbelt housing and would use the ’94 Brownfield sites rated as suitable’ to build 25,000 new homes.

He also supports the building of new rail lines and stations, including a station at Leeds Bradford International airport.

He proposes an expert-led transport review to assess Leeds’s situation and also thinks a Leeds-Bradford tram system should be considered.

Buxton’s main proposal is to replace Leeds & Bradford City Councils with smaller district councils, meaning local councils stay accountable for their actions.

The Liberal Democrat candidate Alisdair McGregor made very clear that he was anti-Brexit from the off-set.

McGregor told the audience that the Lib-Dems would challenge Brexit until it happened.

He stated: “Brexit will ruin this country. It will ruin the future of youth and it will ruin the world as a whole.”

He talked of Labour’s previous failings with tuition fees, stating there were no tuition fees before Labour introduced them in 1998.

This led Labour candidate Ian McCargo to challenge McGregor saying that pre-2010 the Lib-Dems had fully voted against tuition fees.

He said: “The Lib-Dems talking about tuition fees is farcical. The Lib-Dem candidates in 2010 signed a pledge to never support tuition fees and they turned round shamelessly as soon as they got into bed with the Tories and voted in favour on tuition fees”.

Upon becoming a coalition government with the Tories, the Lib-Dems had co-signed an act which trebled tuition fees to £9,000.

McCargos’s main focus was on economic inequality, where he used his daughter’s current situation as an example. He spoke of unaffordable housing, a rise in living costs and the wages of younger people.

Martin Hemingway, of the Green Party, wants to abolish tuition fees. Hemingway was a Leeds City Councillor for 12 years.

He used to be a part of the Labour Party but, following the illegal invasion of Iraq under Tony Blair, decided the Green Party was for him.

Michael Wharton, who is standing as an independent candidate, wants better protection for whistleblowers. He believes that if there’s a whistleblower, then MP’s will be held account and therefore be more cautious with their spending.


The audience vote


A ballot was put forward to the audience before and after the debate. Before the debate Labour were outright leaders with 55% of votes going their way.

The Conservative party received 21% of votes, The Green Party and the Yorkshire both received 7% of votes and the remaining 6% was split equally between the Lib-Dems and the Independent candidate.

After the debate, Labour’s lead had fallen to just 34% of the votes. The Green Party managed to treble their votes, capturing 26% of the votes. The Yorkshire Party also doubled their original tally, putting them in third place.

The Conservatives went from 11 votes to 7 and the Independent candidate lost half of his original vote. The Lib Dems gained one extra vote.

Where Creative Commons images are used on this site we endeavour to credit the owners of those images.